Building Trust as a New Manager

When you’re stepping into a new management role—whether it’s your first time leading or you’re taking over a new team—one thing becomes clear almost immediately: your success depends on your ability to build trust as a new manager. Without it, even the best strategies fall flat, and even the most talented teams underperform. But when trust is present, it becomes the foundation for engagement, collaboration, and sustainable performance.

The challenge? Trust isn’t granted with a title. It’s earned through consistent actions, small decisions, and the way you respond when things get tough. While you may feel pressure to establish authority quickly, the most respected managers lead with credibility—gained by showing up with integrity, fairness, and care.

In this article, we’ll break down the essential mindsets and behaviors that help new managers build trust with their teams—and how even small missteps can cost you more than you think. You’ll also learn how senior leaders can support new managers in growing their leadership confidence. If you’re committed to becoming a leader that people trust, these strategies will set the groundwork.

Why Building Trust Is the Cornerstone of Effective Management

Trust isn’t a “nice to have” in leadership—it’s a non-negotiable. You can’t choose to make it irrelevant or deprioritize it. Employees will automatically develop a level of trust or distrust in you and that’ll impact their perspectives and performance. When employees trust their manager, they’re more engaged, productive, and committed to their work. And the data backs it up.

According to MIT Sloan research, employees who trust their leadership are 260% more motivated to work, have 41% lower rates of absenteeism, and are half as likely to be actively looking for a new job. A separate study published in Harvard Business Review found that people at high-trust companies experience 74% less stress, 50% higher productivity, and 76% more engagement.

For new managers—especially those stepping into a role with an unfamiliar team—building trust early on is vital. Unlike technical skills or subject matter knowledge, trustworthiness isn’t visible on a résumé. It’s something your team will sense in how you show up, how you make decisions, and how you treat people from day one.

Without trust, teams second-guess decisions, avoid tough conversations, and resist feedback. But when trust is present, it unlocks everything else: open communication, healthy conflict, innovation, and accountability. In short, trust is the bridge between your role as “the boss” and your potential as a true leader.

The Trust Bank: A Daily Investment in Leadership

Think of trust like a bank account. Every interaction you have with your team is either a deposit or a withdrawal. When you listen to feedback, give credit, follow through on commitments, or show up consistently—you’re making small but meaningful deposits. Over time, these add up, building a solid reserve of trust.

But the opposite is also true. One action that signals disrespect or dishonesty—a broken promise, a dismissive comment, taking credit for someone else’s work—can drain that account in an instant. And when the trust account hits zero, your team may disengage, doubt your intentions, or stop bringing issues to your attention.

Even worse? If the damage is deep enough, you could end up in a trust deficit—where it takes months of consistent effort just to regain a baseline level of confidence and safety.

That’s why the everyday moments matter more than you think. Trust isn’t built through grand gestures or big decisions. It’s built through patterns—how you listen, how you respond under pressure, and how you treat people when no one’s watching. Each of those is a chance to invest or to withdraw.

In the next section, we’ll explore the specific behaviors and mindsets that build trust, and show how to make regular, intentional deposits into your leadership “trust bank.”

How to Build Trust: Foundational Behaviors and Attitudes That Matter

Trust is earned through how you show up every day – your words, your behaviors, and your mindset. The following core behaviors create the conditions your team members need to feel safe, seen, and supported. Each one is a chance to make intentional deposits into your trust bank, or to chip away at it.

Be Consistent and Create Psychological Safety

One of the fastest ways to earn your team’s trust is to be consistent. When your team knows what to expect from you—your mood, your decision-making, how you respond to mistakes—they’re more likely to speak up, take risks, and stay engaged. This isn’t just about routines—it’s about building psychological safety.

Psychological safety means people feel safe to express ideas, admit mistakes, and offer feedback without fear of being embarrassed or punished. It’s a key ingredient in high-performing teams. In fact, Google’s landmark Project Aristotle study found that psychological safety was the single most important factor in successful teams.

Inconsistent behavior from managers, like overreacting one day and staying silent the next, creates confusion and anxiety. It sends the message that it’s safer to stay quiet than to take initiative. But when you follow through on your commitments, treat people with steady respect, and respond calmly under pressure, your team begins to trust that they can rely on you.

Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

Lead by Example and Assume Positive Intent

As a manager, your team takes their behavioral cues from you. If you want transparency, accountability, and professionalism—you have to model it first. That means showing up with integrity, owning your mistakes, and treating everyone with respect, no matter their role, tenure, or work style.

But leading by example isn’t just about performance or policy. It’s also about mindset. One of the most powerful ways to build trust is to assume positive intent—and encourage your team to do the same.

When someone misses a deadline or says something that rubs you the wrong way, it’s easy to jump to conclusions. But assuming positive intent means pausing to consider that they may have a valid reason, or that their intent wasn’t to harm or undermine. This shift in thinking helps reduce unnecessary conflict and builds a culture where people feel safe to be human.

As a manager, you set the tone. If your team sees you leading with empathy, staying accountable, and giving others the benefit of the doubt, they’re more likely to do the same. Over time, that consistency builds credibility—and credibility builds trust.

Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

Show You Care – Be Curious, Present, and Real

One of the fastest ways to gain trust is also one of the simplest: show your team that you genuinely care about them. Not just their output—but their perspectives, experiences, and goals. When people feel seen and valued, they’re more likely to engage, contribute ideas, and stay loyal to the team.

Start by asking thoughtful questions—and then actually listen to the answers. Get curious about how your team members like to work, what motivates them, and what’s getting in their way. You don’t need all the answers. In fact, the best managers don’t rush to fix—they listen to understand.

Being present is just as important. That means giving people your full attention during one-on-ones, asking follow-up questions, and noticing what’s not being said. It’s about being there, not just sitting there.

Also be real. You don’t need to overshare, but being honest about your own learning curve or showing humility when you don’t know something sends a powerful message: it’s okay to be human here. That kind of leadership invites trust.

It’s equally important to recognize that your team members are human, too. They have families, personal responsibilities, and lives outside of work. Sometimes, those realities will overlap with their job—whether it’s a sick child, a personal loss, or simply the need to recharge. When you show empathy for the whole person, not just the employee, you reinforce that trust is built on respect, not just performance. Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

Respect Differences and Promote Fairness

Every team is made up of people with different backgrounds, perspectives, and communication styles—and that’s a strength, not a barrier. When managed well, those differences lead to better ideas, stronger decisions, and more resilient teams.

As a manager, part of your role is to understand how each person operates so you can help them succeed. That doesn’t mean accepting unproductive behaviors. It means being aware of differences—like someone needing time to reflect before responding, or another who thrives in brainstorming sessions—and adapting your communication and collaboration methods to bring out the best in each team member. Respect doesn’t mean lowering standards; it means being fair and intentional about how you engage.

You also set the tone for how team members treat one another. Encourage a culture where people listen respectfully, remain open to differing viewpoints, and adjust how they work together when needed. Have expectations for how team members engage with each other. And when they aren’t followed, respectfully guide the group back toward collaborative norms. Over time, you’re teaching your team how to work through differences, not around them.

Fairness is just as essential. That means applying expectations consistently, recognizing contributions equitably, and being transparent about how decisions are made. When people feel like they’re playing on a level field and that there’s space for different voices to be heard, trust grows naturally.

Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

Give Credit and Empower Ownership

Micromanaging kills trust. It sends the message that you don’t believe in your team’s ability to make decisions or deliver results. On the flip side, giving people appropriate ownership over their work and acknowledging their contributions builds confidence and loyalty.

New managers sometimes feel pressure to have all the answers or tightly control outcomes. But real leadership means stepping back and letting others lead. This doesn’t mean being hands-off. It means being clear about goals, offering support when needed, and trusting your team to get there in their own way.

And don’t underestimate the power of public recognition. Giving credit where it’s due shows your team that you see and value their efforts—and that you’re not in it for the spotlight. Just make sure you give recognition in alignment with your team members’ personal preferences.

Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

Stay Steady through Difficult Times

James Lane Allen stated, “Adversity does not build character—it reveals it.” How you react under pressure says more about your leadership than how you act when everything is going smoothly. Your ability to stay calm, constructive, and grounded during challenges builds lasting trust.

That doesn’t mean you need to be emotionless. It means responding instead of reacting. Take a breath before replying to that tough email. Don’t assign blame in the heat of the moment. When your team sees that you stay level-headed under stress, they’ll trust you more—not just with tasks, but with their concerns, mistakes, and ideas.

When things go wrong (and they will), your reaction can either reinforce your team’s confidence in you—or cause them to retreat and disengage.

Trust Deposits and Withdrawals

A Note to Senior Leaders: How to Support New Managers

New managers don’t build trust in a vacuum—they do it within the culture and expectations set by senior leadership. If you’re in a higher-level role, your support can make the difference between a manager who survives and one who thrives.

Start by modeling the same trust-building behaviors you want your new managers to use with their teams. That means being consistent, listening with curiosity, assuming positive intent, giving credit, and staying calm under pressure. When senior leaders lead by example, they don’t just talk about culture—they actively shape it.

Offer your new manager coaching and space to grow. That means being available for guidance, encouraging reflection, and helping them navigate tough situations without stepping in to take control. It’s tempting to want to “fix” things quickly, especially when a new manager stumbles—but doing so too often can undercut their credibility and confidence.

Trust your managers enough to let them lead. Give them room to manage conflict, make decisions, and develop their own leadership style. Providing autonomy while offering a safety net builds both trust and capability. However, make sure you’re available when they need support. Not giving them guidance or perspective when they need it can result in choices that will withdraw from their team’s trust accounts.

And finally, share parts of your own leadership journey—not as a model to copy, but as a way to normalize growth. Talk about early challenges, what you learned from failure, and the support that helped you along the way. These real, human stories remind new leaders they’re not alone—and that they’re not expected to be perfect.

Leadership development isn’t a one-time event. It’s a long game. And the way you show up for your new managers will shape how they show up for their teams.

Final Thoughts: Building Trust Is the Real Work of Leadership

When you’re a new manager, it’s natural to focus on proving yourself. But the truth is, your credibility doesn’t come from having all the answers or making bold decisions—it comes from the trust you build, day by day, with your team.

That trust is built through consistent, intentional actions: how you listen, how you handle adversity, how you give credit, and how you support your people. And while it can take time to grow, one misstep can quickly undo that progress. That’s why trust-building isn’t something you “perfect”—it’s something you protect, with care and consistency.

At TopTalent Learning, we help companies strengthen leadership at every level. Our leadership development programs focus on real-world behaviors that build trust and confidence. Whether you need scalable solutions or custom programs tailored to your company’s culture and goals, we can help you equip new managers—and those who support them—with the skills that matter most.

Return to Blog Home page.